Home » Columns » Currently Reading:

Paying Players Not Likely to Happen or Solve Problems

August 26, 2011 Columns No Comments

The subject of paying players in addition to the scholarships they receive is certainly not a new one. Questions have been asked about it for quite a while, with many feeling like players should be paid and for a litany of reasons from television contracts to coaches’ contracts to sales of player jerseys. And while the discussion seems poised to go to another level now that the NCAA is exploring the subject, two things remain true: pay for play will be very difficult to make reality, and if it ever becomes reality it’s not likely to solve the problem of NCAA violations that proponents think it will.

By now, we’re all familiar with a rash of NCAA violations that have happened in recent years regarding extra benefits. Players have accepted cash, jewelry, electronic items, cars and much more, and there have been allegations of players’ parents or others close to them asking for money to get them to commit to the school. We’re also familiar with how flush with cash the NCAA is, and measures of it are everywhere. There’s the $771 million a year television contract for the NCAA Tournament in men’s basketball, as well as the nearly $2 million a year that NCAA President Mark Emmert takes home in salary.

The usual argument for paying players looks at those signs of riches, then notes how players don’t get a penny of it. They say that a scholarship, which nowadays is worth over $40,000 a year at many schools, is simply not enough. They mention the added costs of attendance, which are not insignificant, and the commissioners of the Big Ten and SEC have spoken in favor of allowing their member schools to include this for their athletes.

All of them make some sense on a basic level. Economics and other realities change all of that.

While it’s true that new television deals are helping big-time programs become flush with cash, it’s not spreading to all schools. Most of the big money also comes from football, which is the driver behind a lot of things like new deals and conference shuffling. In fact, many schools get a large amount of their revenue from things like student fees and ticket sales. Hence the big money deals that make the news might skew the perception, but the reality is a little different for many schools.

For a good example, one need only look to last season’s big story in the NCAA Tournament. After signing head coach Shaka Smart to a new contract nearly quadrupling his salary, VCU announced a plan to raise student fees by $50 per student. More than a third of the fee goes toward intercollegiate athletics.

It doesn’t end there. If you’re going to pay the Heisman candidate running back or the star point guard, you also have to pay the third-string quarterback who may never be good enough to play in a non-blowout as well as the project center who barely gets off the bench because he’s so raw. For that matter, you can’t just pay the football and men’s basketball players (and perhaps the men’s ice hockey players in some schools as well) – there are also the baseball players, women’s volleyball, track and field, and so forth.

With the sheer number of athletes that covers, even paying them $100 a month will generate a fairly large bill that a lot of schools aren’t likely to be able to afford. And if you think a school can avoid this issue by just paying the revenue sport athletes, think again. This is a litigious society we live in, and as such that is sure to be contested legally, especially with Title IX in place.

But even if this could be taken care of somehow – whether some form of revenue sharing like we’ve seen in pro sports leagues or some other measure – it’s far from a given that this would put an end to extra benefit violations. In fact, a look at human behavior and the desire for more shows that cracking open the door the slightest bit won’t keep it there – instead, it would lead to people blowing the door open and crashing through to try to get more. Paying players wouldn’t stop at just giving them a small amount of money; you can be sure schools would try to find ways to pay some players a good deal more than that in violation of new rules. In addition, as that happens, players getting paid leads to violations then being harder to prove, as illustrated in an excellent column on the subject by colleague Pat Forde of ESPN.com.

One might say that instead of all of this, why not make the athletes employees? That brings along its own set of issues that are not easily resolved, not the least of which is that once again, all of the athletes would have to be employees, not just the football and men’s basketball players.

Talking about pay for play is not a bad idea. It is a conversation worth having. But at the end of the day, not only does it face serious headwinds to adoption, it also doesn’t seem likely to solve the problem proponents hope it will. Proponents of the idea probably shouldn’t get their hopes up.

Comment on this Article:

Subscribe to Hoopville

Enter your email address to subscribe to Hoopville


Hoopville Archives

College Basketball Tonight

We hope you enjoyed COLLEGE BASKETBALL TONIGHT during the 2016 NCAA Tournament. COLLEGE BASKETBALL TONIGHT is a comprehensive look at the NCAA Tournament hosted by veteran college basketball broadcaster Ted Sarandis, along with co-hosts Mike Jarvis and Terry O'Connor, both former Division I coaches. It also included many great guests, including Hoopville's own Phil Kasiecki.

The show aired on AM 710 WOR in New York City on Sunday evenings starting with Selection Sunday and running through the NCAA Tournament.

Here are links to the shows:

March 13, 2016 - First hour | Second hour

March 20, 2016 - First hour | Second hour

March 27, 2016 - First hour | Second hour

April 3, 2016 - First hour | Second hour

Coaching Changes

The coaching carousel is moving. Keep track of the latest coaching changes right here on Hoopville.

Everybody Needs a Head Coach

Former college basketball coach Mike Jarvis has a new book out, Everybody Needs a Head Coach.

"As you read this book, I hope that Coach Jarvis' experiences inspire you to find your purpose in life."
-Patrick Ewing, NBA Hall of Fame center

"Mike Jarvis' is one of my special friends. I am so pleased that he has taken the time to write this fabulous book."
-Mike Krzyzewski, Five-time NCAA championship head coach, Duke Blue Devils

"In reading this book, I can see that Mike hasn't lost his edge or his purpose. Readers should take a look at what he has to say."
-Jim Calhoun, Three-time NCAA champion, UConn Men's basketball

Review on Hoopville coming soon!

Hoopville Podcasts

College Basketball Tonight – March 19, 2018

March 20, 2018 by

We discuss the wild early rounds of the NCAA Tournament, joined by special guest Kevin McNamara of the Providence Journal for one segment. In addition, we touch on coaching news and other issues surrounding the college game.

Talking Hoops With Ted Sarandis – March 17, 2018

March 17, 2018 by

In our latest podcast, there is one main story to focus on: history being made in Charlotte and its aftermath. But we also talk about tough times for the Pac-12 and a key member school, plus an added challenge ahead at Pittsburgh.

College Basketball Tonight – March 11, 2018

March 12, 2018 by

College Basketball Tonight returns with a comprehensive look at the NCAA Tournament bracket, and in the second segment Mount St. Mary’s head coach Jamion Christian joins us.

Talking Hoops With Ted Sarandis – March 10, 2018

March 10, 2018 by

As Championship Week nears its climax on the big Saturday, we look at a pair of semifinals and a lot of bubble teams that may be sweating it out on Sunday.

Talking Hoops With Ted Sarandis – March 8, 2018

March 8, 2018 by

As Championship Week heats up, we talk about bubble teams who may or may not want to earn their way into the NCAA Tournament, as well as a couple of mid-majors whose conference championship game was played earlier in the week.

Phil Kasiecki on Twitter

Recruiting Coverage

Lincoln captures Hamilton Park title

August 15, 2017 by

For the first time, a public school won the Hamilton Park Summer League, and they were led by a big effort from a junior point guard in the title game.

Notes from a day at the 2017 Boston Shootout

June 12, 2017 by

Some news and notes coming from the second and final day of action at the 2017 Boston Shootout, where the host program provided plenty of talent, but so did a program that produced a team that beat them.

Notes from a day at the 2017 Northeast Hoops Festival

April 11, 2017 by

The Northeast Hoops Festival helped bring in the new spring travel season in New England, and we have notes from some of Saturday’s action.

2016 Boston Back to School Showcase notes

September 12, 2016 by

We look back at the 2016 Boston Back to School Showcase, where a couple of Boston City League teams were among the most impressive on the day.

2016 Hoopville Spring Finale championship recap

June 28, 2016 by

We look back at the championship games of the 2016 Hoopville Spring Finale, which had a big local flavor as one might have expected.